(2016) AUC Interpretationes 6 (1-2).

Le voyageur et le pouvoir magique

une étude de la Wissenschaftslehre

Luis Fellipe Garcia

pp. 55-71

This article advances the hypothesis that the Fichtean enterprise of grounding all possible experience in a fundamental principle has to fail in order to succeed one of its most important tasks: reformulating the very idea of subjectivity. In order to ground this hypothesis, the paper will be divided in four parts: (i) the first one will analyze the starting point of the work where Fichte lays the foundations of his philosophical project (Grundlage der gesamten Wissenschaftslehre) so as to show that its first principle contains a fundamental ambiguity. We will then (ii) suggest that this very ambiguity reveals itself in the Anstoß, the conceptual tool through which Fichte intends to get rid of the Kantian notion of thing-initself. In a third moment (iii), we will explore the effects of this abandonment of the thing-in-itself on the relation between the finite and the infinite, what will bring us to the notion of failure. Finally (iv), we will propose to interpret this failure as a positive driving force of a permanent calling into question of the subject and its language.

Publication details

DOI: 10.14712/24646504.2017.13

Full citation:

Fellipe Garcia, L. (2016). Le voyageur et le pouvoir magique: une étude de la Wissenschaftslehre. AUC Interpretationes 6 (1-2), pp. 55-71.

This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.