237935

(1995) Synthese 102 (1).

For whom the Bell arguments toll

James Hawthorne, Michael Silberstein

pp. 99-138

We will formulate two Bell arguments. Together they show that if the probabilities given by quantum mechanics are approximately correct, then the properties exhibited by certain physical systems must be nontrivially dependent on thetypes of measurements performedand eithernonlocally connected orholistically related to distant events. Although a number of related arguments have appeared since John Bell's original paper (1964), they tend to be either highly technical or to lack full generality. The following arguments depend on the weakest of premises, and the structure of the arguments is simpler than most (without any loss of rigor or generality). The technical simplicity is due in part to a novel version of the generalized Bell inequality. The arguments are self contained and presuppose no knowledge of quantum mechanics. We will also offer a Dutch Book argument for measurement type dependence.

Publication details

DOI: 10.1007/BF01063901

Full citation:

Hawthorne, J. , Silberstein, M. (1995). For whom the Bell arguments toll. Synthese 102 (1), pp. 99-138.

This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.